Overthinking The Awesome
You've tried meditation. You've tried breathing exercises. You've been told to "just relax" or "stop worrying so much."
And yet here you are—3 AM, wide awake, your brain running worst-case scenarios about something that happened years ago or might never happen at all.
Your brain isn't broken. It's brilliant and bored.
Overthinking the Awesome is a six-episode podcast series for anyone struggling with anxiety, overthinking, intrusive thoughts, and the mental spirals that steal your sleep and your peace. Instead of trying to silence your racing mind—spoiler: it doesn't work—you'll learn to redirect all that mental energy into clarity, confidence, and calm.
In this series, you'll discover:
- How to catch "the click"—the split-second before anxious thoughts spiral out of control
- Why your inner critic won't shut up and how to finally fire your negative narrator
- How to retrain your mental algorithm so it stops feeding you catastrophic thinking and worry
- Why compliments feel suspicious, why imposter syndrome kicks in when things go right, and how to let positive things be true about you
- Real strategies for calming a restless mind without toxic positivity or empty affirmations
This is a self-help podcast for overthinkers, worriers, perfectionists, and anyone whose brain treats 2 AM like prime problem-solving time. If you've ever wished you could just turn your mind off—or wondered how to stop overthinking everything—start here.
Topics covered include: overthinking, anxiety, self-doubt, rumination, negative self-talk, inner critic, intrusive thoughts, worry, catastrophic thinking, imposter syndrome, mindset, mental wellness, self-improvement, cognitive reframing, confidence building and more.
Based on the book Overthinking the Awesome: How to Turn Anxiety, Spiraling, and Self-Doubt Into Clarity and Confidence by David Cosgrove, which is available on Amazon, Kindle + Paperback and on Audible.
Overthinking The Awesome
Episode 3: Firing Your Narrator
That voice in your head that critiques every move, predicts disaster, and reminds you of every mistake? It's time for a performance review. If you struggle with negative self-talk, self-doubt, or an inner critic that never lets up, this episode teaches you how to replace that harsh narrator with a supportive coach—without toxic positivity or pretending the voice doesn't exist.
📖 Read the book on Amazon: Overthinking the Awesome — Kindle + Paperback Available ➤ https://www.amazon.com/Overthinking-Awesome-Spiraling-Self-Doubt-Confidence-ebook/dp/B0G53WXKCV/
🔈 Listen on Audible ➤ https://www.audible.com/pd/B0GD2LD5XG
From the space between send and reply, this is Overthinking the Awesome with David Cosgrove. Welcome back. You're thinking too much. Good. So am I. Let's put that big brain of yours to work. Before we get started, I want to give a quick thanks to this episode's sponsor, Westwood Provisions, handmade candles out of Simsbury, Connecticut. When I'm recording or writing, the right atmosphere matters. These folks get that. Connect with Westwood Provisions on Instagram and Facebook. Tell them the Overthinker sent you. So if you want to know how you really feel about yourself, listen to what your brain says when you drop something. Mine used to yell, ha, nice job, genius. Not oops, not no big deal. Full blown biting sarcasm. Like a disappointed sitcom dad who's seen it all before. That's when I realized I'd given my inner narrator the personality of someone I would never hire to run my actual life. The narrator, that voice, narrating your every move. It's not your core identity. It's a habit of language that got hired years ago and never got a performance review. It learned its tone from parents, teachers, culture, trauma, whoever talked the loudest and most often. Then it built a script of greatest hits. You're lazy. You always screw things up. You should be farther along by now. The problem isn't that it talks, it's that it never got new material. So, here's what we're going to do. We're going to fire that narrator and hire a new one. Let's talk about the rewrite. Step one. Catch the broadcast. Start noticing the phrases that pop up when things go wrong. You'll likely see patterns, the same three or four greatest hits of self-doubt playing on a loop. Step two. Write yourself a new script. When the old narrator pipes up with wow, you really messed that up, jump in like a screenwriter doing rewrites. The old familiar line. Your new line. Okay. That was clumsy, but also kind of funny. Moving on. Keep it short, witty, and slightly loving. The goal isn't to sound like a motivational poster, is to sound like a friend who's both kind and relentlessly on your side. Step 3. Pick a genre. Every story has a tone. Choose one for your life that fits the best. Comedy. Every mistake is just a setup for a future punchline. Documentary. The subject has spilled the coffee. A minor setback. Here we see the fascinating ritual of dabbing with a napkin. The sports commentary. Oh, a bold attempt. Just missed the execution. Let's see how they recover. You get it. Once you know your genre, your brain automatically starts narrating events with that flavor. Hey, the third person hack. A bonus technique. It sounds weird, but it works incredibly well. Instead of saying, I can't handle this, try saying David, you can handle this. Use your own name, third person. Psychologists call it distanced self-talk. When you talk about yourself in third person, your brain shifts from emotional mode to coach mode. Less drama, more logic. It's like you just hired Morgan Freeman to narrate your life. Try it once. It feels weirdly empowering and pretty awesome. Your narrator builds the emotional soundtrack of your life. Change the voice and you change the feeling. So give your new narrator a name that makes you smile and happy. Captain Context. Doctor Reasonable. Aunt Clarity. Whatever works, no matter how stupid or clumsy or clever or happy as it sounds. And when the old narrator starts ranting, step in, just say, ah, thanks. We've got it from here, dude. This has been Overthinking the Awesome. I'm David Cosgrove. Stay safe out there, and remember, your mind isn't too much. You're just learning how to play it. If this episode resonated with you, the book goes even deeper. Overthinking the Awesome How to Turn Anxiety, Spiraling, and Self Doubt into Clarity and Confidence is available on Amazon and Audible. And if you want to share your journey, reach out. I'm at DavidCosgrove.com. Thanks for listening.