Overthinking The Awesome
You've tried meditation. You've tried breathing exercises. You've been told to "just relax" or "stop worrying so much."
And yet here you are—3 AM, wide awake, racing thoughts on repeat, your brain running worst-case scenarios about something that happened years ago or might never happen at all.
Your brain isn't broken. It's brilliant and bored.
Overthinking the Awesome is a podcast for anyone drowning in anxiety, rumination, self-doubt, and the mental spirals that steal your sleep and hijack your peace. Instead of trying to silence your restless mind—spoiler: it doesn't work—you'll learn to redirect all that mental horsepower into clarity, confidence, and calm.
In this series, you'll discover how to catch "the click"—the split-second before anxious thoughts spiral into full-blown catastrophic thinking. You'll learn why your inner critic won't shut up and how to finally fire your negative narrator. You'll retrain your mental algorithm so it stops feeding you worst-case scenarios and worry on a loop. You'll understand why compliments feel suspicious, why imposter syndrome kicks in the moment things go right, and how to let positive things actually be true about you. And you'll get real strategies for quieting a racing mind—without toxic positivity or empty affirmations.
Season 1 laid the foundation. Season 2 goes deeper.
This is a self-help podcast for overthinkers, chronic worriers, perfectionists, and anyone whose brain treats 2 AM like prime problem-solving time. If analysis paralysis has ever frozen you in place—or you've wished you could just turn your mind off for five minutes—start here.
Topics covered include: overthinking, anxiety, self-doubt, spiraling, rumination, racing thoughts, inner critic, negative thinking, worry, anxious thoughts, catastrophic thinking, perfectionism, imposter syndrome, analysis paralysis, intrusive thoughts, cognitive reframing, mental wellness, and building real confidence.
Based on the book Overthinking the Awesome: How to Turn Anxiety, Spiraling, and Self-Doubt Into Clarity and Confidence by David Cosgrove, available on Amazon (Kindle + Paperback) and Audible.
Overthinking The Awesome
Episode 4: Overthinking Work and Performance
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
You finished the project and got positive feedback—so why do you still feel like you didn't do enough? The invisible scoreboard of perfectionism never stops running. David explores why high-performers struggle with imposter syndrome and relentless self-doubt, how self-criticism masquerades as professional diligence, and how to fire your inner critic and hire a coach instead. Discover the "wins file"—a practical tool for building counter-evidence against workplace anxiety—and learn to redirect your analytical mind from punishment toward forward-focused career growth. Caring about your work doesn't have to mean destroying yourself over it.
📖 Read the book on Amazon: Overthinking the Awesome — Kindle + Paperback Available ➤ https://www.amazon.com/Overthinking-Awesome-Spiraling-Self-Doubt-Confidence-ebook/dp/B0G53WXKCV/
🔈 Listen on Audible ➤ https://www.audible.com/pd/B0GD2LD5XG
From the space between send and reply, this is Overthinking the Awesome with David Cosgrove. Welcome back. You're thinking too much. Good. So am I. Let's put that big brain of yours to work. Before we begin, I want to give a quick thanks to this episode's sponsor, Westwood Provisions, handmade candles out of Simsbury, Connecticut. When I'm recording or writing, the right atmosphere matters. These folks get that. Connect with Westwood Provisions on Instagram and Facebook. Tell them the Overthinker sent you. Did I do enough today? You finished the project, met the deadline, got positive feedback, maybe even got praised. And still, somewhere in the back of your mind, there's a scoreboard, an invisible one, and it's never quite satisfied. You could have done more, should have caught that error, should have started earlier, should have been faster, sharper, better. Other people seem to finish their work and move on. You finish your work and it starts. The invisible scoreboard, always running, never satisfied. Here's something nobody tells you. The people who overthink their performance are usually the ones performing well. Think about it. If you didn't care about quality, you wouldn't be analyzing your output. If you didn't have high standards, you wouldn't notice the gaps. If you weren't paying attention, you wouldn't see what could have been better. Your overthinking is a symptom of caring, of competence, of awareness. The problem isn't that you're thinking about your work. The problem is that the thinking has become indistinguishable from punishment. Somewhere along the way, you started believing that being hard on yourself was the same as being good at your job, that self-criticism was the engine of excellence. But anxiety isn't diligence. In beating yourself up isn't the same as getting better. So let's find that click. It usually happens right after you finish something. The project ships. The meeting ends, the email sends, and instead of feeling done, you feel exposed. Like now everyone will see. Now they'll know. Now the flaws are visible. That shift from I completed something to now I'll be judged. There's your click. Or it's the moment you start replaying mistakes instead of registering wins. When your brain fast forwards through the praise to get to the criticism. Notice that. Name it. I just skipped the win to find the flaw. That's the pattern. How do we redirect this? Time to fire that inner critic. Not silence it, fire it, because it's not doing its job. A good critic makes you better. Your inner critic just makes you smaller. So let's hire a different voice. The coach. A good coach notices what went wrong and also what went right. A good coach gives feedback you can use, not just verdicts you can fear. A good coach wants you to improve, not just feel bad. When your brain starts the post-game analysis, ask, is this the critic or the coach talking? The critic says, Oh boy, you should have known better. The coach says, next time try this. The critic says, everyone noticed that mistake. The coach says, Ah, that's fixable. Here's how. The critic says, You're not good enough. The coach says, you're getting better. Same information, completely different voice. Here's the awesome move. Redirect the overthinking into refinement. Your brain wants to analyze your work. Cool. Let it analyze, but point it somewhere useful. Instead of saying, what did I do wrong? Ask, what would I do differently next time? Instead of, was that good enough? Ask, what's one thing I could improve? Instead of, uh, did they notice the flaw? Ask, what did I learn from this? This is the same mental energy pointed forward instead of backward. Analysis that builds instead of breaks. And here's the bonus. Keep a WINS file, a document where you record things that went well, compliments you received, problems you solved, moments you showed up. Your brain won't remember these automatically. It's wired to remember threats, not triumphs. So you have to write them down. The WINS file is your counter evidence, your proof that the invisible scoreboard is wrong. You care about your work. That's perfectly clear. Nobody who didn't care would think this hard about it. But caring doesn't require cruelty, not from others and not from yourself. You can have high standards and still be kind to the person meeting them. Caring deeply doesn't mean punishing yourself. This has been Overthinking the Awesome. I'm David Cosgrove. The book goes a lot deeper. Overthinking the Awesome is available on Amazon and Audible. Questions or topics? Hit me up at DavidCosgrove.com or find me on Instagram at Dell Piombo Music. Stay safe out there and remember, your mind isn't too much. You are just learning how to play it.